Why Tungsten Carbide Wear Parts Pit and Lose Size in Wet Slurries Even When Hardness Is High
I’ve been looking at tungsten carbide parts for twelve years, and one failure mode still catches people off guard: the surface starts pitting and the dimensions drift even though the carbide grains themselves haven’t worn much. It shows up most often in wet milling, slurry pumps, and any application where the cobalt binder stays in contact with water or mild corrosives for long periods. Hardness stays high because the tungsten carbide grains are still there. What disappears is the cobalt that holds them in place.
Most cemented carbide grades rely on a cobalt binder. In dry abrasion that binder is protected. Once water, process chemicals, or even mildly acidic slurries are present, the cobalt can slowly leach out. The carbide grains loosen, small pits form, and the part loses size faster than a simple wear calculation predicts. Higher-cobalt grades are tougher but usually corrode faster. Lower-cobalt or nickel-bonded grades resist this better but can be more brittle under impact.
Lab data from a slurry exposure test
We took standard 8% cobalt tungsten carbide coupons and ran them in a stirred slurry of fine silica in water at 40°C for 200 hours. Weight loss was modest, but surface roughness increased and shallow pits appeared. Cross-sections showed cobalt depletion to a depth of 20–40 µm in the worst areas, with loose carbide grains at the surface. Hardness measured on the pitted surface dropped locally even though the bulk hardness remained around 1500 HV. A parallel set with a corrosion-resistant nickel binder showed almost no pitting and far less surface degradation under the same conditions. The difference was clear once the binder was no longer cobalt.
Field case from a wet grinding circuit
A mineral processing plant was running tungsten carbide wear sleeves in a wet ball mill discharge area. The sleeves were a standard cobalt-bonded grade chosen for abrasion resistance. After about four months the internal diameter had opened up more than expected and the surface was covered in small pits. Material throughput and media size hadn’t changed. When we sectioned a used sleeve, the outer working surface showed the same cobalt-depleted layer we’d seen in the lab, while the unwetted mounting surfaces looked normal. The slurry pH was running between 5.5 and 6.5 with some dissolved salts. Switching to a lower-cobalt grade with a more corrosion-resistant binder cut the diameter growth roughly in half over the next campaign, even though the pure abrasion resistance was slightly lower. The pitting slowed enough that the sleeves lasted through the scheduled maintenance window.
What actually drives the pitting
Cobalt leaching doesn’t need highly acidic conditions. Prolonged contact with water plus any oxygen or mild contaminants is often enough, especially if the part sees temperature cycles that open micro-cracks at the surface. Once the binder starts to leave, abrasive particles in the slurry can pluck out the unsupported carbide grains and the damage accelerates. Dry applications rarely show this; the problem is almost always tied to continuous or frequent wet exposure.
Edge preparation and surface finish matter less here than binder chemistry. A smoother surface can delay the start of pitting, but it won’t stop cobalt loss if the environment is aggressive enough. Some operations add inhibitors or control pH to slow the attack; others simply move to nickel-bonded or specially formulated corrosion-resistant carbide once they confirm the mechanism.
If tungsten carbide parts are losing size through pitting rather than uniform abrasive wear, and they’re running wet, the binder is usually the weak link. Checking whether the grade is cobalt-bonded and whether the slurry stays in contact for long periods explains most of these cases faster than re-measuring bulk hardness. The carbide grains are still hard—they just aren’t held as tightly once the cobalt begins to leave.